45,000 reviews analyzed
Winner
Delta FaucetThe DELTA FAUCET Morgan Round Front Slow-Close Toilet Seat is designed for round-front toilets and offers a few practical features that many users will appreciate. Its slow-close function prevents the seat from slamming shut, which reduces noise and wear over time. Non-slip bumpers keep the seat securely in place, so it won’t move around during use. Installation is straightforward and secure, making it easier for most people to replace or upgrade their current seat without professional help.
Made from white plastic, it’s lightweight but sturdy enough for everyday use. One thing to keep in mind is that it fits only round-front bowls, so it won’t be compatible with elongated toilets. Also, since it is a basic plastic seat, it lacks extra comfort features like padding or advanced materials sometimes found in higher-end seats.
If you’re looking for a reliable, quiet, and easy-to-install toilet seat for a standard round toilet, this model is a solid choice. However, if you need a seat for an elongated toilet or want added luxury features, you might want to explore other options.
MayfairThe Mayfair Padded Toilet Seat is designed to add extra comfort to your bathroom experience. Its cushioned soft vinyl cover over a wood core makes sitting more comfortable, which is especially helpful for seniors, post-surgery recovery, or anyone sensitive to hard toilet seats. The round bowl shape fits many standard toilets with a round seat design, though it is not suitable for elongated bowls.
This seat is relatively easy to maintain thanks to an Easy-Clean hinge system that allows for quick removal, making hygiene simpler. Installation is straightforward with the STAY-TITE Fastening System, which helps keep the seat securely in place without loosening over time. The white color and simple styling make it a neutral choice for most bathroom decors. However, as a padded vinyl seat, it may require more careful cleaning than hard plastic seats to avoid damage from harsh cleaners. It is also heavier than some plastic-only seats due to its wood core, which could be a minor consideration during installation.
This seat does not affect the toilet's flush system, water usage, or rough-in size since it is an accessory rather than a full toilet. If your toilet uses a round seat and you want added comfort, this seat is a solid, budget-friendly option with a well-reviewed reputation. If you need a seat for an elongated bowl or want a non-padded option, this would not be the right fit.
MayfairThe Mayfair Benton Toilet Seat is a solid choice for anyone looking to upgrade their elongated toilet with a stylish and functional accessory. Its oval shape and matte black metal hinges give it a modern, sleek look that can enhance most bathroom décors. Made of wood, this seat feels sturdy and comfortable while being built to resist cracking, warping, or staining, which is great for busy households.
The slow-close feature is a quiet and safe addition, preventing loud slams and finger pinches. Installation is straightforward and can be done by most users without professional help, saving time and money. It fits standard elongated toilets from popular brands like American Standard and Kohler, making it widely compatible.
Since it is a wood seat, it requires gentle cleaning to maintain its finish, and those wanting plastic or more lightweight options might look elsewhere. It doesn’t include any advanced flush or water-saving features since it’s a seat rather than a full toilet. For those prioritizing a durable, quiet, and visually appealing toilet seat with easy installation, this product satisfies those needs well.