45,000 reviews analyzed
Winner
The Philips Hue Tap Dial Switch offers a unique approach to smart light control with its no-wire installation and push button design. It functions as a 3-way switch and supports smooth dimming, making it convenient to mount anywhere without worrying about wiring or neutral wires—ideal for renters or those who want easy setup.
It integrates into the Philips Hue ecosystem, allowing access to preset light scenes through physical controls rather than relying solely on an app. The switch uses a battery included with the device, so occasional replacement is needed. Its compact and white plastic design is simple and unobtrusive but may not suit all décor preferences.
Users looking for a straightforward, battery-powered smart dimmer with tactile buttons and flexible placement will find this product appealing. Those wanting deep voice control or more advanced app customization may find its capabilities somewhat limited compared to fully networked smart switches.
The Philips Hue v2 Smart Dimmer Switch is designed for users who want a simple, wireless way to control Philips Hue smart lights with dimming and preset lighting scenes. It’s a single-pole switch that connects wirelessly via the Hue Bridge, rather than directly through Wi-Fi or Zigbee, meaning you’ll need that extra hub to unlock full functionality and customization. One of its biggest conveniences is the battery-powered, wireless design with adhesive and magnetic mounting options, letting you place it anywhere or use it as a portable remote.
It features touch-sensitive buttons for easy on/off and dimming control, and you can cycle through four preset light modes like Read and Relax with a dedicated button. Since it’s wireless, it doesn’t require a neutral wire, which makes installation straightforward without electrical rewiring. Voice assistant control isn’t built into the switch itself but can be accessed via the Hue Bridge and compatible assistants like Alexa or Google Assistant.
The app control requires the Hue Bridge, allowing you to tailor scenes and manage multiple rooms or zones remotely. This switch is ideal for people already invested in the Philips Hue ecosystem who want flexible, remote lighting control without hardwiring. If you’re looking for a smart switch that works independently of a hub or offers direct voice control on the switch, this won’t fully meet those needs. For Philips Hue users, it offers a neat, versatile way to brighten, dim, and set moods easily around the home.
The SmartSetup Matter Thread Smart Switch is a one-gang ON-OFF switch designed to work well in modern smart home setups. It supports multiple voice assistants including Apple HomeKit, Alexa, Google Home, and SmartThings, making it flexible for various smart ecosystems. One standout feature is its use of Thread connectivity with Matter support, which means it offers fast, reliable, and local control without relying on the cloud, helping ensure your switch works even if the internet is down. This switch also works with or without a neutral wire, which is great for older homes where neutral wires are often missing.
It includes a Smart Bulb Mode, letting you keep your favorite smart bulbs while still controlling brightness and color through the switch or voice commands. It lacks built-in dimming capability since it operates strictly as an ON-OFF switch, so if you want to dim your lights directly from the switch, this may not meet that need. The device has a clamp connector for easy installation and handles standard home voltage with a 10-amp current rating, suitable for most household lighting circuits. Its design is simple and functional, with a white finish and a normal button style, fitting well in most home decors.
The switch also acts as a Thread network router, helping expand your home mesh network for better connectivity. While it doesn’t have advanced app features or extensive customization options, it provides solid remote control and automation through the supported platforms. This product is ideal for those seeking a reliable, privacy-focused smart switch that integrates smoothly with multiple smart home systems and future-proofs the setup with Matter and Thread technology. If dimming or multi-way switch setups are needed, alternative options might be more suitable.