45,000 reviews analyzed
Winner
The Makita DJR189Z is a lightweight, 18V cordless reciprocating saw designed for general wood cutting tasks. It features a brushless motor and an integrated counterweight system that significantly reduces vibration, helping to reduce user fatigue during longer cuts. With a stroke speed of 3100 strokes per minute, the saw delivers relatively fast performance. The fixed shoe design slightly limits its versatility compared to models with adjustable shoes that provide more control on angled cuts.
Weighing just 816 grams, the saw is easy to handle and carry around, making it suitable for users who need a tool that won’t cause fatigue quickly. It offers constant speed control to maintain performance even under heavy loads, which is advantageous for tougher jobs. While the saw is optimized for wood cutting, it may not be ideal for more demanding materials like metal or masonry.
This Makita saw is a solid choice for DIYers or professionals who require a reliable, low-vibration tool for wood cutting projects, although it may lack some features that would enhance versatility and convenience.
MilwaukeeThe Milwaukee M18CSX2-0 is a cordless reciprocating saw powered by an 18V lithium-ion battery (battery not included). Weighing about 3.5 kg, it balances portability with solid build quality, though it might feel a bit heavy for extended use. The brushless motor enhances efficiency and tool life.
Milwaukee’s SAWZALL series is known for strong cutting power suitable for metal and other tough materials, making this model a reliable choice for metalwork and general demolition. It features an anti-corrosion design and a rubber handle for better grip and comfort. Since it comes as a bare tool, you'll need to purchase the battery and charger separately.
The package dimensions suggest a compact design. If you want a durable, professional-grade saw that can handle heavy-duty jobs and already own compatible Milwaukee batteries, this saw fits the bill well. However, new users or those needing a complete kit should consider the additional costs for batteries and chargers.
The Milwaukee M18 Fuel Hackzall is a powerful, cordless reciprocating saw designed for one-handed use, making it ideal for working in tight or awkward spaces. Its 18V battery power and brushless motor deliver strong performance, supported by a 22mm stroke length and a fast speed of up to 3000 strokes per minute, allowing for quick, efficient cuts, especially on metal surfaces. Weighing around 2 kg, it balances power and portability, providing comfort for extended handling.
The tool features Milwaukee’s Redlink Plus intelligence for optimized performance and a dual gear counterbalance mechanism that reduces vibration, helping to minimize user fatigue. This model is sold as a bare tool, which means the battery and charger need to be purchased separately, potentially increasing the overall cost if you do not already own compatible Milwaukee batteries.
This saw is well-suited for professionals or serious DIYers who require a reliable, fast-cutting, and compact reciprocating saw. If you need a complete kit, ensure that the battery and charger are included or available separately.